Personal Relationships Are More Important Than Politics

Today, I wrote a check to Campus Crusade for Christ, an organization that believes that I am contributing to the decay of society. However, personal relationships are more important than politics. And it is only through personal relationships that any substantive change can take place.

The decision to write the check came about a couple weeks ago when a former student sent me a note asking if I would support his upcoming trip to East Asia. In a private note that accompanied his more formal request for support, he wrote that “I have seen how Christ’s love has changed my life and the lives of students here at Schoolcraft College.” His formal letter explained how he will have the opportunity to share the love of Christ while building personal relationships with other students whom he will encounter during his travels.

My former student explained that he has “seen how Christ’s love has changed my life and the lives of students here at Schoolcraft College.” I have seen the same thing as I have worked closely with him and other such students in my classes.

I have many of the same doubts about the leadership and political message advocated by Campus Crusade for Christ that I developed when I first encountered the organization more than 30 years ago when I was a student at Michigan State University. Yet, I have also seen how the lives of individual students who struggle with their Christian faith are improved while trying to incorporate Christ’s message into their daily affairs.

Although I follow the Buddha Dhamma in the Theravada Tradition, I take comfort in the words of His Holiness the Dalai Lama when he teaches that “We cannot say that one religion is best. I am a Buddhist but I can’t say Buddhism is the best religion. It depends on a person’s perception of what is best for him.” This understanding allows me to both disagree with the political positions taken by Campus Crusade for Christ and to be able to support my former student in what should prove to be a wonderful educational experience that will facilitate much personal growth.

Even though my former student believes that his is the right path, he is like most Christians whom I encounter on an individual basis. He desires to share his deep faith with others but tries not to impose it on them. He leads by his quiet example.

My former student is not like the prominent Christian minister who has been grabbing headlines this Easter weekend by advocating a hate filled message against Muslims. The student’s preparations to study and to travel and to quietly share his faith will never capture the attention of the media, but that is not the point of his efforts. He desires to quietly touch lives on an individual level. And whether he does this as a Christian or a Buddhist or whatever path is best for him, his efforts are worth supporting. Compassion breeds compassion in others. Non-violence, like violence, in mimetic.

In his private note to me, he wrote that “I truly am thankful for our relationship and I consider it a privilege to have been one of your students. I have learned a great amount from you and I would be truly honored to receive your blessings and support.” I too, am thankful for our relationship and look forward to being his prayer partner as he continues on his path. Furthermore, I am equally honored to have received his blessing and support.

    –Steven L. Berg, PhD


Creative Commons License

11 Responses

  1. Chad Schaffer says:

    This post really has me thinking Dr. Berg. Your primary point is a profound one. I recently revisited my position on “The Religion Issue”, and this post has come at a perfect time to temper some of my more radical sentiments. Thank you.

  2. Bob Czuprynski says:

    Disentangling religion from politics is a difficult task. At the individual level religion can be transformative and bring an awareness of a spiritual connection promoting love and compassion, but at the political level it often undermines this truly liberating aspect of religion by promoting dogmas promoting distinctions and hate. It sounds like your student has gained spiritually, and I hope he isn’t obstructed in this pursuit by the dogmas of Campus Crusade of Christ.

  3. christa says:

    Steve, I thought what you wrote, and the decision you made, was selfless and kind. You thought about your student and his path instead of your own. You gave to made his dreams come true, not yours. You showed him the respect to take a different path and still call him friend. I am moved by the choice you made, albeit a difficult one for you.

  4. Diamond Vinson says:

    To do that for him dispite the different views you have toward his path in religion, shows your generosity and there are not a lot of people out there these days.

  5. Sam Hays says:

    I have been a Lutheran minister, an academic, an activist, and an agnostic. Now I am still an activist, attend a Quaker meeting and soon hope to be a Quaker, a group that spans from pentecostals in Africa to evangelical Christains, humanists, and Buddhists in America. Quakers have different thoughts but a strong commitment to a common spirit. When I recently said to a Quaker that I take my ideas seriously, she replied, “You will get over that.”

    • christa says:

      haha…i love that resonponse! “you will get over that.”
      I was not aware of the vast span of thought included in the Quakers. Is there no doctrine…or is their doctrine inherently subjective? just curious. 🙂 I know they are non-violent and I’ve always respectived their values.

      • sam hays says:

        My understanding is that it is more about seeking than doctrine, although I have heard that some of the evangelicals can become doctrinaire. My experience is with the unprogrammed who have no ministers, no sermons, no collections. You meet quietly for an hour and if anyone is inclined, she speaks. Half of their business meetings involve discussing such issues as integrity. But it is not done as an argument. People who desire share and no rebuttal comments are made. I lived among Quakers as a child and went to a Quaker college, So I have always had an affection for them.

  6. Seth Porter says:

    While I respect the decision here, I am surprised at it. Putting personal relationships before politics can be a tricky choice. I have had experience with Campus for Christ, and I view the group as homophobic, close minded, and insensitive. I find their views on a singular path to heaven as well as their views on women’s rights and the right of gays and lesbians to be offensive. I realize that there are those who may find some sort of happiness in that type of exclusionary group, and while I applaud emotional transcendence of any type, I would not give funds to support what I consider anti-Christian ideas for any reason. You have given funds to an organization that preaches that you are hellbound simply by virtue of your Buddhist faith. That is a difficult concept for me to grasp.

    • Seth, I pretty much agree with your analysis of Campus Crusade for Christ. But the tricky part is, what does one do when an individual—my former student—is given a wonderful opportunity by a group whom I do not respect. Do I give priority to the larger organization or the individual? It is a tricky proposition and one I struggled with before writing the check. It is also a situation where I think that thoughtful people acting in good faith could come to very different decisions.

  7. Beth Vonck says:

    Teachers who truly care are like gardeners nuturing and tending their gardens. We hope that some of the ideas we have planted take root, mature, and blossom. How wonderful it is when we discover just how many of our students have also planted their own seeds that are enriching to our lives! Like you, I take such pride in my students and their gifts give me hope. We are so very lucky to be in this profession.

  8. Glenn Sunshine says:

    Relatively few people in academia have the best interests of the students in mind–they’re more concerned in my experience on their causes than in the transformation of a student’s life for the better. I appreciate your care and compassion for your student and your willingness to extend yourself to help him do valuable work, even coming from a very different faith from your own. Bravo.

LEAVE A COMMENT