November 24: Photographs Don’t Lie?

On 24 November 1963, there was the first live television broadcast of a murder when Jack Ruby shot Lee Harvey Oswald while Oswald was being transferred from the Dallas Police Headquarters to country jail. Two days earlier, on November 22, Oswald had assassinated President John F. Kennedy. Dallas Morning News photographer Ira Jefferson “Jack” Beers Jr. photographed the killing. The now iconic photograph appeared on the front page of the November 25 issue of the Dallas Morning News.

The first photograph was taken by Joseph Nicéphore Niépce in 1926. The exposure time was eight hours. The first photograph of an individual was taken by Louis Daguerre c. 1838.

It was not until 1839 that Sir John Herschel coined the word photograph from the Greek words φῶς (light) and γραφή (drawing). Therefore, a photograph was “drawing with light” which differed from drawing with paint or pencil because it would render a true image. Although a picture might paint a thousand words, a camera could not lie.

Gary Martin writes that “The earliest citation of the precise ‘camera cannot lie’ phrase we have found is from The Evening News, Lincoln, Nebraska, November 1895, complete with an intimation of the early doubts about the literal truth of the phrase:”

Photographers, especially amateur photographers, will tell you that the camera cannot lie. This only proves that photographers, especially amateur photographers, can, for the dry plate can fib as badly as the canvas on occasion.

In 1920, when Sir Arthur Conan Doyle illustrated an article on fairies with photographs taken in 1917 by 16 year old Elsie Wright and 10 year old Frances Griffiths. Doyle believed in fairies and used what are known as the Cottingley Fairies as proof of their existence. In the 1980s, the girls admitted that the photographs had been faked.
Online consultations are an innovation in health order 50mg viagra care that utilizes the Internet to improve patient access to the physician. You might have come across men who have overly large sized cheap tadalafil no prescription http://www.slovak-republic.org/phone/ breasts. Psychiatrists have come across other online prescription viagra rare fears, including a fear of belly buttons and a fear of poverty held by a really wealthy individual who was afraid to stop working. If you are a smoker then try to quit smoking as it can also be a major cause in triggering Erectile Dysfunction in many men and female get suffer with sexual condition due to purchase viagra from india adaptation of unhealthy lifestyle.
In the twenty-first century, photographic evidence is not as easy to believe; especially because of the ease of manipulating digital images. For example, the Beers photograph taken 49 years ago today has been modified to make it look as if Ruby and Oswald played together in a rock band.

–Steven L. Berg, PhD

Photo Caption: Meme showing Jack Beers photograph of Oswald being killed and altered version showing Oswald and Ruby in band. (top) Elsie Wright photograph of Frances Griffiths with a faerie. (bottom)



Although Today in History is primarily student written, there are some days when we do not have a student author. You will enjoy another student entry tomorrow.

14 Responses

  1. Katelyn Pollack says:

    I looked up more information about Nicéphore Niépce and found that he was a pioneer of more than just photography. He also invented a Pyréolophore, which was known as the world’s first ‘internal combustion engine.” He brainstormed and created it with the help of his older brother Claude, and finally received a patent on July 20, 1807 from the Emperor Napoleon Bonaparte, after successfully powering a boat upstream on the river Saône. It’s engine ran on controlled dust explosions of Lycopodium, but ten years later, they were also the first to invent a working engine with a fuel injection system.

  2. Brooke Bode says:

    This is extremely interesting considering so many photos we see today are photoshopped. It’s crazy to think photoshopping pictures have been around as long as that. If you think about it, photoshop affects many lives. For instance, many teenaged girls. When young girls see in magazines how unbelievably attractive supermodels are, over and over again, it makes them believe that’s what the definition of beautiful is; very slender, perfect tan, perfect teeth, perfect proportional face, acne free, long luscious hair, and perfectly done excessive amounts of make-up. And if you think about it, the only people shown in magazines or on television are supermodels. This is where the whole eating disorders and tons of beauty products start to take over teenage girls, because everyone want to be that “perfect” famous supermodel. When in reality, most if not all of the photographs you see are photoshopped. From the smallest thing to skin brightening or changing the shape of a woman’s breast size, photoshop is everywhere. Photoshop is to the extreme today where a model can look completely different in person than on the cover of a magazine.

  3. Makenzy Wilson says:

    Not only does Photoshop affect much of what pictures portray to the society, but also the angle of the shot. Two outstanding pictures were taken the day Oswald, John F. Kennedy’s alleged assassin, was transferred to the County Jail; one picture was taken by Robert Jackson and the other by Beers. Beers shot his picture at a higher angle, thinking he might have a better advantage to see Oswald. Jackson, a photographer for the Dallas Time-Herald at the time, took his shot over the heads of other reporters and newsmen less than a second later. Because Jackson was held for questioning thereafter, Beers’ picture was the first published and viewed by the public. Immediately, Beers and his colleagues thought his incredible photograph would win the Pulitzer. Jackson’s picture was published soon after he was released and it was his picture that received the Pulitzer, not Beers. The difference in which the picture was taken would release a new view on the whole scene.

    -Makenzy Wilson

  4. Heather Daugherty says:

    Photography has always been a passion of mine. I once wanted to pursue a career as a professional photographer, but I think I have pretty much grew out of that. Nonetheless, photography has always held my interest, especially the pinhole cameras. By definition, a pinhole camera is a camera with a pinhole as an aperture instead of a lens. Light from a scene passes through this single point and projects an inverted image on the opposite side of the box. You use light sensitive photo paper, that upon long exposure to the light, and when is fixed on one single object for a long enough time, will produce that picture on the paper. It can be a very long and particular process. Anyone can make a pinhole camera usually out of everyday ordinary cereal boxes, or any other type of household box type trash objects.

    http://www.thefreedictionary.com/pinhole+camera
    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pinhole_camera
    http://www.hometrainingtools.com/pinhole-camera-science-project/a/1322/

  5. Adam Rababeh says:

    I actually do not like Photoshop because it used to be that pictures were worth a thousand words in history, and cannot be altered. I do like this joke of a picture on Oswald. In Lincoln’s 2nd inaugural speech on March 4, 1865, John Wilkes Booth was there. Not only there for the event, but very close to the President in the famous picture right above Lincoln in the top right. I found that very interesting and thought I should share it.

  6. Raquel Murillo says:

    Its amazing to see what photoshop has turned into today. Some photoshop softwares sell for up to 499+ at best buy. Though stuff like that are typically bought by big marketing and or advertising companies. Having taken a digital imaging class myself, it still amazes me how far the digital world has come. The things photoshops allows us to do like, make someone go from 300 pounds to 100 pounds. You can age a person, touch up old photos, edit bad ones, so on and so forth. Though photoshop is still not free for public use it is great for those with artistic talents and good knowledge of (mac) computers. I don’t think magazines componies like ‘Cosmo’ and ‘Seventeen’ would be what they are today without photoshop.

  7. Crystal Heidler says:

    Photographs have been around for years, since the first one taken in the 1820’s. Back then they were only black and white photos. The first recorded color photo was taken in 1862 thanks to James Clerk Maxwell who was a physicist who was experimenting with using the three-color-separation in 1855. Today modern photos take just minutes – seconds to produce and email. Photos taken on smart phones can be instantly uploaded to any select site or sent to any person or place. Photo are chariest moments in time that take people back to time were they were their happiest. Photos are taken to remember places, object and people, photos are one of the more permeant ways of keeping record of and event. Though photos are just there to jolt a person memory of some time, the memory of that event will out last any photo. There are many modern way to chance the way a photos design and even ways to alter what the picture captures. The most popular way is “photoshop” The software is designed to give the user ultimate control of their photos and give way for the user to create a one of a kind photo.

  8. Alan Hammell says:

    (Following with Brooke B.)
    Photoshop is nothing more than a manipulative tool used to alter opinions, truths, and character. It’s not used to make a picture more pleasant, but to change what the eye really sees. Photoshop has taken over the industries of popular magazines, for all ages, including Teen Bop or Cosmo, and modeling to give a sense of the “picture-perfect” or completely disappointing anything.
    In today’s world, everyone has a visual problem. Maybe it’s the fact you suffer from acne, or that your house isn’t up to Hollywood Blvd standards, but there’s always something. The unfortunate part of it all is the fact that society belittles 100% of its people because of the implanted idea of going “easy on the eyes”.
    People of society set a mental standard for themselves and others around them, but because of these “pictures” they see, it plants a seed within their mind of what life should be like. Not only that, but what you should look like, who you should be with, etc.This is part of the reason that eating disorders and suicide rates have been out the window, but not to mention how cruel mental disrespect can be on a day to day bases anyway.

    • Matt Solomon says:

      An important fact to keep in mind when discussing Photoshop is its uses outside of the strict realm of photo manipulation. Many illustrators and arguably all graphic designers use Photoshop (or any other similar graphics editing program) to create anything from magazine covers to website logos. It is an important technological tool for many professions, and should definitely not be written off as some sort of evil tool of fact manipulation. Sure, it can and is often used as such, but its practical uses for graphical design which creates a livelihood for many far outweighs its uses as a simple photo-editing tool to smooth blemishes or define curves.

  9. Chris Duncan says:

    the name Sir Arthur Conan Doyle of course reverberated with me, myself being and avid Sherlock Holmes fan, so I looked into his obsession with fairies and found out he had an obsession with mysticism and the afterlife after his wife, son, brother, and two brother in laws died. These deaths drove him to want to know if there was such thing as an afterlife so he could have peace of mind.

  10. Jessica Linderman says:

    Photoshop on photos is not a new idea. In Ancient Egypt it was a common thing for kings to wipe out the art or history left behind by their predecessor. A prime example of this would be King Akhenaten, better known as the “Heretic King”. When he ruled he drastically changed the religion of Egypt along with the physical capital. After Akhenaten and his son King Tut ruled, a new family ruled Egypt. The majority of the Egyptian people disagreed with the huge changes that Akhenten and his son made, so they got rid of any proof of him. Much like Photoshop they simply erased the marks that Akhenaten made.

  11. Trevor Corn says:

    Photoshop has always been an issue, as giving someone the ability to change something is very tempting. Look at the Sphinx in Egypt, artwork of it always differes and changes drastically depending on who is drawing/rendering it.

    http://www.africanbynature.com/falseimages/bewarefalseimages.html

    If you look down towards the bottom of the page, you will notice at least 5 different rendering of the sphinx, with the earliest one being handdrawn in 1798. Just goes to show that a form of photoshop has always existed, just tech has made it easier for the average person to accomplish.

  12. The further back in history we go, the more genuine things were. Look back on fast food restaurants and you will notice that food was more consumer friendly as compared to the substances we are ingesting today. I believe the same goes for pictures.

    Society doesn’t depend on authenticity anymore. Todays culture relies on rumors, yellow journalism, and conspiracy theories. We are in a trending revolution of trends and memes and products such as Photoshop and other advancements in technologies will further push us into a darker, less genuine place.

  13. Meagan Nystrom says:

    Being an art student I realize just how easy it is to be able to change photos. Photoshop has been going on for a while but the website for it (or at least Adobe) was created in 1988. It was created in January but was not released until later that year in October. Since then it has gone through tens of upgrades improving every little detail we know and care about today. In high school we were required to do Photoshop projects in art, and it can vary from being simple common knowledge to the most difficult thing in the whole wide world. I’m personally one for keeping the photos I take as real and genuine as possible (photographer on the side) so Photoshop may be spiffy and all, but in my eyes will never beat out the ordinary photo of a Polaroid camera.

Leave a Reply